Wednesday, October 31, 2012

"We don't take action against scientists and forecasters presumably because we understand the nature of science"

http://www.deseretnews.com/article/765614158/Jailing-Italian-scientists-discourages-discovery-in-scientific-community.html

In our opinion: Jailing Italian scientists discourages discovery in scientific community


"We don't take action against scientists and forecasters presumably because we understand the nature of science. A forecast is a reporting of probabilities based on observable conditions, taking into account that those conditions can change in unpredictable ways. If we held scientists accountable for every failed prediction, they eventually would cease to base those predictions on data, choosing instead to err on the side of caution in order to minimize their own liabilities.
As absurd as it sounds, an Italian court has turned these presumptions upside down by convicting seven Italian scientists to six years each in jail for manslaughter because they failed to predict a deadly earthquake. Some claim the reporting in this case has stoked unneeded controversy, saying the crime wasn't a failure to predict the quake, but a failure to communicate the risks to the public. That is so small a distinction as to be nonsensical. The scientists observed a series of minor tremors, then gave inexact and unclear information about whether those were precursors to a larger quake." 






No comments:

Post a Comment