Biosecur Bioterror. 2014 Apr 2. [Epub ahead of print]

Do Latin American Scientific Journals Follow Dual-Use Review Policies?

Valles EG1, Bernacchi AS.

Author information

• 1Edith Galdys Valles, DVM, PhD, and Adriana Silvina Bernacchi, PhD, are Technical Advisors, Scientific and Technical Research Institute for Defense , Buenos Aires, Argentina .

Abstract

During the past decade, a number of journals have implemented dual-use policies in order to analyze whether the papers submitted for publication could raise concern because of the potential for misuse of their content. In this context, an analysis was performed on Latin American scientific journals to examine whether they apply formal written dual-use review policies and whether they inform their authors and reviewers about potentially sensitive issues in this area, as other international journals do. Peer-reviewed life sciences journals indexed in Latindex from Brazil, Mexico, Argentina, and Chile were analyzed. The Guide for Authors and the Instructions to Referees of 216 journals included in the Latindex catalogue (which means that they meet the best quality standards of the Latindex system) were screened for biosecurity-related information using the keywords biosecurity, biological weapons, and dual-use research of concern. Results showed that the screened publications had a total lack of dual-use review policies, even though some of them pointed out ethical behaviors to be followed related to authorship, plagiarism, simultaneous submission, research results misappropriation, ethical principles for medical research involving human subjects, guiding principles for the care and use of animals in research, research standard violations, and reviewer bias, among others.