Nannystate: "...there is no firm evidence on the effects of smoking bans on smoking."

Health Econ. 2013 Nov 6. doi: 10.1002/hec.3009. [Epub ahead of print]

DO PUBLIC SMOKING BANS HAVE AN IMPACT ON ACTIVE SMOKING? EVIDENCE FROM THE UK.

Jones AM1, Laporte A, Rice N, Zucchelli E.

Author information

• 1Department of Economics and Related Studies (DERS), University of York, UK.

Abstract

The literature on the effects of public smoking bans on smoking behaviour presents conflicting results and there is limited evidence on their impact on active smoking. This paper evaluates the impact of smoking bans on active smoking using data from the British Household Panel Survey and exploiting the policy experiment provided by the differential timing of the introduction of the bans in Scotland and England. We assess the short-term impact of the smoking bans by employing a series of flexible difference-in-differences fixed effects panel data models. We find that the introduction of the public smoking bans in England and Scotland had limited short-run effects on both smoking prevalence and the total level of smoking. Although we identify significant differences in trends in smoking consumption across the survey period by population sub-groups, we find insufficient evidence to conclude that these were affected by the introduction of the smoking bans. These results challenge those found in the public health literature but are in line with the most recent strand of economic literature indicating that there is no firm evidence on the effects of smoking bans on smoking.